A Blue Anchor Update

The Blue Anchor British Pub in Delray Beach, Florida has had a rough time of it lately. I did a post about the place back in December, after it had been closed down due to "extensive rodent infestation and serious sanitation failures." And so, when I went down to Delray Beach a few weeks ago for "The Delray Affair" (an arts and crafts festival), I checked the place out and was surprised to find it was open. When I got home, I looked The Blue Anchor up on the internet and found an article in the Palm Beach Post detailing a pretty turbulent past few months. Health code violations triggered six temporary closures in December 2025 and another five in February. A March 2nd state inspection resulted in still another temporary closure, but it was cleared to reopen the same day. Regular blog readers will recall that The Blue Anchor was originally built in London in the 1840s. Legend has it that a woman named Bertha Starkey, who lived above the pub, was caught with her lover by her husband, who murdered them both. When the pub was torn down to make way for an office building, its Tudor-style facade and wood interior were removed and shipped to New York. They stayed there until 1996 when the pieces were shipped to Delray, and the Blue Anchor was resurrected on Atlantic Avenue right next to the Intercoastal Waterway. And yes - Bertha Starkey also made the trip across the Atlantic and still haunts the place.

Sadly, the health department closures are not the pub's only problem. Landlord Delray Beach Associates has filed a lawsuit alleging unpaid rent of almost $70,000. Restaurant broker Tom Prakas negotiated the deal to bring The Blue Anchor to Delray Beach, and in a recent interview said that landlord Burt Handelsman paid to have the pub pieces brought to the site, which is part of the Handelsman family's real estate holdings in Delray Beach. His adult children still own the property through Delray Beach Associates. In any case, the pub, a favorite of local soccer fans, especially those following the English Premier League, was indeed still open for business when I stuck my head through the front door and snapped the photograph on the right. Nobody knows what The Blue Anchor's fate will be, but 70K in back rent seems like a pretty steep tab to pay off. Restaurant broker Prakas hopes that if the landlord does take it back, The Blue Anchor will remain the way it is. All of the other restaurants on Atlantic Avenue are expensive modern hotspots, without the charm of an old English pub. The Blue Anchor, after all, is a local landmark. And besides, where would all those soccer fans go otherwise?